User talk:Liagdan

Regarding your statements made on Northeast Donetsk Campaign

Hey there, a few days ago, you left a few comments on Northeast Donetsk Campaign which I thought I’d clear up for you.

I see you asked me and @Bukansatya a question regarding the article’s readiness, however we did not respond due to not noticing it. If you would like a speedy response (and have good reason for a speedy response), feel free to use the tagging feature by using the @ symbol.

However, I have noticed that upon another editor responding with their thoughts on the article, you attempted to suggest that Bukansatya and I agreed with you and your stance on the article, despite us never replying nor explicitly stating our opinions. You then proceeded to say that the discussion was “finished” and that we didn’t want to talk about it anymore. This is an inappropriate comment on your behalf for many reasons. In Wikipedia, unless it was a formal discussion which was closed, all editors are free to join in on a discussion at any time and give their opinions on the topic, and you attempting to push away another editor by stating such is simply inappropriate and rude. You also made the claim that we “didn’t want to talk about it anymore”, despite such claims never being stated by us. Attempting to lie about other editors’ stances to help support your own viewpoint is against Wikipedia policy and should be avoided.

If this behaviour continues, I will not hesitate to take it to ANI. I’d like to assume good faith however I do not see how such a mistake could happen when there is evidently 0 proof to support yourself.

I chose to help edit your draft and provide feedback to help you and your article, as well as to provide you with necessary feedback for you to self improve on. However, do not take these edits and feedback as me showing support to decisions you make. If you would like to know my stance on something, there is no harm in asking me.

Also, I cannot help but notice that on Talk:Northeast Donetsk Campaign, you made a comment stating that @Broskalitre is your brother. This contradicts previous statements of yours in which you claimed that this account is an alt account of yours on a different device. This could fall under Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry and you should probably tread lightly and properly establish what is going on with these two accounts before any future conflict arises. IiSmxyzXX (talk) 07:55, 4 May 2025 (UTC)[reply]

My brother sometimes use this phone. But I left you a message on SaintPaulofTarsus page and the Northeast Donetsk Campaign page. Again, I apologise and if you take this to ANI, I will not oppose it but take it as an opportunity to learn but I hope you will listen to my message in those two pages. Thank you. Liagdan (talk) 16:15, 4 May 2025 (UTC)[reply]

Also, I am not attempting to “lie” about your stance. I am drawing conclusions based on the discussion above and that we weren’t really talking about it but just focusing on editing the page and for more clarification, you may look into the messages I left for you in the Northeast Donetsk Campaign talk page and SaintPaulofTarsus talk page . But I would still take it that me and my brother were the backbone of that page even if the users who created the body of that page have been forgotten and have been thrown away.I hope you will still look into the messages I left in the 2 talk pages . Thank you. Liagdan (talk) 16:49, 4 May 2025 (UTC)[reply]