Pope Formosus

Pope Formosus
Bishop of Rome
1493 drawing of Pope Formosus by Bartolomeo Sacchi
Church	Catholic Church
Papacy began	6 October 891
Papacy ended	4 April 896
Predecessor	Stephen V
Successor	Boniface VI
Personal details
Born	c. 816 Rome, Papal States
Died	4 April 896 (aged c. 80) Rome, Papal States

Pope Formosus (c. 816 – 896) was the pope and ruler of the Papal States from 6 October 891 until his death on 4 April 896. His reign as Pope was troubled, marked by interventions in power struggles over the Patriarchate of Constantinople, the Kingdom of West Francia, and the Holy Roman Empire. Because he sided with Arnulf of Carinthia against Lambert of Spoleto, Formosus's remains were exhumed and put on trial in the Cadaver Synod. Several of his immediate successors were primarily preoccupied by the controversial legacy of his pontificate.

Early career

Formosus was Born around 816 within the papal states of Italy in the area surrounding Rome. ^[1] Formosus's career became notable within the church when he was appointed as cardinal bishop of the suburbicarian diocese of Portus in 864.^[2] Shortly thereafter, Pope Nicholas I sent Formosus as a legate to Bulgaria in 866 where he served as a papal envoy and participated in the ordinations of Slavic followers of Cyril and Methodius of Rome. In 867, Boris I requested that Formosus be named archbishop of Bulgaria due to his connection with the bishop. The church did not allow Formosus tochange sees as Formosus already held the position of Archbishop of Portus. The transfer of sees went against church canon as the church viewed Archbishops similarly to the way they viewed marriage. Bishops could not change sees unless it served the best interests of the church, and Formosus's transfer was seen as transmigration, or the transfer of episcopal sees in the pursuit of personal ambition.^[3] He also undertook diplomatic missions to France in 869 and 872.^[4]

Upon the death of Holy Roman Emperor Louis II of Italy in 875, the nobles elected his uncle Charles the Bald as the new emperor. Formosus conveyed Pope John VIII's invitation for Charles to come to Rome to be crowned. Charles took the crown at Pavia and received the imperial insignia in Rome on 29 December. The supporters of Louis' other uncle, Louis the German, and of Louis's widow, Engelberga, opposed the coronation. Fearing political retribution, many of them left Rome surreptitiously. Formosus fled to Tours.^[5] On 19 April, John VIII called a synod which ordered Formosus and other papal officials to return to Rome. When Formosus did not comply, he was removed from the ranks of the clergy and excommunicated on the grounds that he had deserted his diocese without papal permission, and had aspired to the position of archbishop of Bulgaria. Additional charges included the accusations that he had opposed the emperor; "conspired with certain iniquitous men and women for the destruction of the Papal See"; and had "despoiled the cloisters" in Rome.^[5] The condemnation of Formosus and others was announced in July 876.^[6] In 878 the sentence of excommunication was withdrawn after he promised never to return to Rome or exercise his priestly functions.^[7]

As early as 872 he was a candidate for the papacy; Johann Peter Kirsch suggests that the Pope may have viewed him as a potential rival.^[6] In 883, John VIII's successor, Pope Marinus I, restored Formosus to his suburbicarian diocese of Portus. Following the reigns of Marinus, Pope Adrian III (884–885), and Pope Stephen V (885–891), Formosus was unanimously elected Pope on 6 October 891.^[5]

Papacy

A 16th century depiction of Formosus's Papacy, from the Facial Chronicle

Shortly after his election, Formosus was asked to intervene in the Patriarchate of Constantinople, where Photius I had been ejected and Stephen I, the son of Emperor Basil I, had taken the office. Formosus refused to reinstate those who had been ordained by Photius, as his predecessor, Stephen V, had nullified all of Photius's ordinations. However, the Eastern bishops determined to recognize Photius's ordinations nonetheless. Formosus also immediately immersed himself in the dispute between Odo of Paris and Charles the Simple for the French throne. Siding with Charles, Formosus zealously exhorted Odo to cede the throne to Charles, to no avail.

In 888 CE, Charles “The Fat” died without an heir, just three years before Formosus became the Pope. Almost a century after Charlemagne had been crowned emperor, the last son of the legitimate Carolingian line of succession had fallen. Seeing an opportunity to seize more power, Guy III, the marquis of Spoleto, drew up key support from other wealthy aristocrats and summoned an army to meet Berengar, a prominent descendant of Charlemagne through a female line of succession, at the Battle of Trebbia in 889. Guy defeated Berengar and seized “the iron crown of the regnum Italiae [Kingdom of Italy]”^[8] for himself. Now the King of Italy, Guy turned his gaze unto Rome.

Formosus later involved himself in another conflict, in which Arnulf of Carinthia, the King of Germany, was marching through Tuscany on his way to Rome, and was met with the forces of Guy III of Spoleto, now the Roman Emperor, at the gates of Ivrea.^[9] Arnulf took the city after a siege, which began a feud between the two powerful figures. Formosus had trouble maintaining the goodwill of Guy, which caused him to become deeply distrustful of Guy and begin to look for support against him. To bolster his position, Guy forced Formosus to crown his son Lambert as co-emperor in April 892. Stephen V and Formosus became the first two popes to crown a non-Carolingian man Emperor of Rome in almost a century, presenting the title to Guy III, the marquis of Spoleto, and later to his son, Lambert. The following year, however, Formosus persuaded Arnulf of Carinthia to advance to Rome and liberate Italy from Guy's control, as the faction of “Spoletans” aligned themselves with Agiltrude, Guy’s wife. In 894, Arnulf's army occupied all the country north of the Po River. Guy died in December, leaving his son Lambert in the care of his mother, Agiltrude, who was an opponent of the Carolingians. In autumn 895, Arnulf undertook his second Italian campaign, progressing to Rome by February and seizing the city from Agiltrude by force on 21 February. The following day, Formosus crowned Arnulf as emperor in St. Peter's Basilica. The new emperor moved against Spoleto but was struck with paralysis on the way and was unable to continue the campaign.

During his papacy, Formosus also had to contend with the Saracens, who were attacking Lazio.^[10] While Muslims encroached upon Christian territory, Formosus took a staunch anti-diplomatic approach as pope, supporting violent military campaigns to eliminate the foreign threat and reinstate the Papacy’s influence over the area. Emperor Guy led these campaigns until his death in 894, and other rulers took up the cause after him.^[11] On 4 April 896, Formosus died.^[12] He was succeeded by Boniface VI, whose papacy lasted 15 days.^[12] The death of Formosus resulted in Boniface VI being elected in an uncanonical manner.

Legacy

Further information: Cadaver Synod

The Cadaver Synod as portrayed by Jean-Paul Laurens in 1870

Stephen VI, the successor of Boniface VI, influenced by Lambert and Agiltrude, sat in judgment of Formosus. In 897, nine months after Fomosus's death, in what is known as the Cadaver Synod, where the popes body was exhumed and forced to stand trial. The Synod was an attempt for the church to distance itself from the memory of Formosus, and was an example of violence being used to destroy the symbolism behind the former pope. The corpse was disinterred, clad in papal vestments, and seated on a throne to face all the charges from John VIII. The verdict stated that the deceased pope had been unworthy of the pontificate, and the damnatio memoriae was applied to Formosus. All of Formosus's measures and acts were annulled, and the orders conferred by him were declared invalid. The papal vestments were torn from his body, the three fingers from his right hand he had used in blessings were cut off, and the corpse was thrown into the Tiber, later to be retrieved by fisherman.

Following the death of Stephen VI, Formosus's body was reinterred in St Peter's Basilica. Further trials of this nature against deceased persons were banned, but Sergius III (904–911) reapproved the decisions against Formosus. Sergius demanded the re-ordination of the bishops consecrated by Formosus, who in turn had conferred orders on many other clerics, causing great confusion. Later, the validity of Formosus's pontificate was re-reinstated. The decision of Sergius with respect to Formosus has subsequently been universally disregarded by the Catholic Church, since Formosus's condemnation had little to do with piety and more to do with politics.

Liudprand of Cremona's Account

Few primary sources document the life of Formosus or the events of his posthumous Cadaver Synod, as it presented such a blight on the reputation of the Holy See.^[13] The most well-known account comes from Liudprand of Cremona (c. 920-972), a historian, diplomat, and later Bishop of Cremona. His book, Antapodosis (Retribution) offers a secondhand account of the events, written roughly 60 years after the synod took place. Composed for the records of Bishop Recemundus of Elvira, Liudprand included Formosus as part of a wider analysis on late-Carolingian era Italy.^[14]

Liudprand wrote Antapodosis during a period of exile from the court of King Berengar II of Italy. As Berengar held very loose familial connection to the Carolingian dynasty, his legitimacy relied on a perception of longstanding social stability. Liudprand sought to ruin this perception and discredit his rival. His work connected the desecration of Formosus’ body to a corrupt and chaotic church protected by Berengar’s predecessors. As a result, historians recognize that the coverage of the Cadaver Synod in Antapodosis likely contains added details that exaggerate the savagery of the event.

References

Footnotes

1. Kirsch 1909, p. 139.
2. Kirsch 1909, p. 139; Mann 1910, p. 46.
3. Heath, Christopher; Houghton, Robert (2022). Conflict and Violence in Medieval Italy 568-1154. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press. pp. 185–197. ISBN 978 94 6298 517 9.
4. Kirsch 1909, pp. 139–140.
5. Kirsch 1909.
6. Kirsch 1909, p. 140.
7. Mann 1906, p. 357: "And it is not unlikely that it was because John VIII. saw that Formosus might easily become the tool of designing men – or that at least the faction which had secured his interest might cloak their nefarious plans under the good name of the Bishop of Porto – that he forbade him to come to Rome again."
8. Salazar, Igor Santos (2021). "Shaping a Kingdom: The Sees of Parma and Arezzo between the reigns of Louis II and Berengar". In Gantner, Clemons; Pohl, Walter (eds.). After Charlemagne: Carolingian Italy and Its Rulers. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. p. 125. ISBN 9781108840774.
9. Moore, Michael E. (2014). Ecclesia et Violentia: Violence against the Church and Violence within the Church in the Middle Ages. Newcastle-upon-Tyne: Cambridge Scholars. pp. 184–208. ISBN 978-1-4438-6659-0.
10. Wickham 2014, p. 22.
11. Wolf, Kordula (2022). "'Nec patiaris populum Domini ab illis divinitus fulminandis Agarenis discerpi': Handling 'Saracen' Violence in Ninth-Century Southern Italy". In Heath, Christopher; Houghton, Robert (eds.). Conflict and Violence in Medieval Italy 568-1154. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press. pp. 164–165. ISBN 9789462985179.
12. Kirsch 1909, p. 141.
13. Barritt, David (2022). "Formosus and the 'Synod of the Corpse'". In Heath, Christopher; Houghton, Robert (eds.). Conflict and Violence in Medieval Italy 568-1154. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press. p. 186. ISBN 9789462985179.
14. of Cremona, Liudprand (2007). "Antapodosis". In Squatriti, Paolo (ed.). The Complete Works of Liudprand of Cremona [Retribution]. Washington D.C.: Catholic University of America. pp. 64–66. ISBN 9780813215068.

Bibliography

• Biography portal
• Christianity portal

• Brusher, Joseph (1959). "Sergius III". Popes Through the Ages. Neff-Kane. Archived from the original on 1 February 2008. Retrieved 2 January 2008.
• Darras, Joseph-Epiphane (1898). A General History of the Catholic Church. Vol. 2. New York: Excelsior Catholic Publishing House. Retrieved 31 January 2018.
• Gregorovius, Ferdinand (1903). The History of the City of Rome in the Middle Ages. Vol. 3 (2nd ed.). London: George Bell & Sons.
• Kirsch, Johann Peter (1909). "Pope Formosus" . In Herbermann, Charles G.; Pace, Edward A.; Pallen, Condé B.; Shahan, Thomas J.; Wynne, John J. (eds.). Catholic Encyclopedia. Vol. 6. New York: Encyclopedia Press (published 1913). pp. 139–141. This article incorporates text from this public-domain publication.
• Mann, Horace K. (1906). The Lives of the Popes In The Early Middle Ages. Vol. 3. London: Keegan Paul, Trench, Trübner & Co. Retrieved 1 February 2018.
•  ———  (1910). The Lives of the Popes In The Early Middle Ages. Vol. 4. London: Kegan Paul, Trench, Trübner, & Co. Retrieved 8 January 2008.
• Miley, John (1850). The History of the Papal States From Their Origin to the Present Day. Vol. 2. London: T.C. Newby. Retrieved 1 February 2018.
• Milman, Henry Hart (1867). History of Latin Christianity. Vol. 3 (4th ed.). London: John Murray.
• Mosheim, Johann Lorenz von (1852). Institutes of Ecclesiastical History, Ancient and Modern. Vol. 2. Translated by Murdock, James (5th ed.). New York: Stanford and Swords. Retrieved 8 January 2008.
• Platina, B. (1479). The Lives of the Popes from the Time of Our Saviour Jesus Christ to the Accession of Gregory VII. Vol. 1. London: Griffith Farran & Co. Retrieved 8 January 2008.
• Wickham, Chris (2014). Medieval Rome: Stability and Crisis of a City, 900–1150. Oxford: Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-103090-1.

Further reading

• Bautz, Friedrich Wilhelm (1990). "Formosus, Papst". In Bautz, Friedrich Wilhelm (ed.). Biographisch-Bibliographisches Kirchenlexikon (in German). Vol. 2. Hamm, Germany: Bautz. cols. 70–71. ISBN 978-3-88309-032-0.

External links

• Media related to Formosus at Wikimedia Commons
• Works by or about Formosus at Wikisource

Catholic Church titles
Preceded by Stephen V	Pope 891–896	Succeeded by Boniface VI