"I'm Coming Home" was Mathis' only release as a solo artist to make it to number one on the BillboardEasy Listening chart. "I'm Coming Home" went to number one for a single week in September 1973.[1] The single was also a minor pop hit; it peaked at number seventy-five on the Billboard Hot 100.[2]
The Spinners re-recorded the song for their 1974 album, Mighty Love, on which writers Thom Bell and Linda Creed also worked. Their version peaked at number eighteen on the Billboard Hot 100 and number three on the Hot Soul Singles chart.[3]